
-Published on Radio Free Europe-
Hashim Thaçi was in detention in The Hague, where he was being tried for war crimes and crimes against humanity, when on December 5, 2024, he was served with a second indictment. This indictment opened a separate case for actions that, according to the Prosecution, were aimed at influencing witnesses in the first trial.
The Specialist Prosecutor’s Office (SPO) claims that, during visits to the detention facility, Thaçi gave visitors confidential information about witnesses and instructions on how they should testify in the trial against him and three other former KLA leaders.
In this case, alongside Thaçi, former director of the Kosovo Intelligence Agency Bashkim Smakaj, former mayor of Malisheva Isni Kilaj, KLA veteran Fadil Fazliu, and former Minister of Justice Hajredin Kuçi are accused.
On September 16, the Special Court found Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi and Jakup Krasniqi guilty of war crimes. Thaçi was sentenced to 25 years in prison. The judgment against all four is expected to be appealed.
Two months later, on November 17, the Special Court is expected to deliver its judgment against Thaçi and the four co-accused in the obstruction of justice case.
The Prosecution sought six years in prison for Thaçi and requested that, if he is found guilty in this case as well, he serve the second sentence after the one for war crimes. For Smakaj, Kilaj and Fazliu it sought three years in prison each, while for Kuçi nine months.
At the closing hearing on September 10, the specialist prosecutor Kimberly West said that Thaçi and the co-accused tried for months to influence witnesses in the trial for war crimes and crimes against humanity.
West described the co-accused as close associates, loyal friends and former subordinates of Thaçi. According to her, he instructed them to contact witnesses whose testimony he considered decisive and to ask them to change what they had said, including about his presence in the places where crimes are alleged to have been committed. West said that recordings of conversations in detention and seized documents supported this claim.
What did the Prosecution say happened during the detention meetings and how did it use the recordings and seized documents to support the charges?
Meetings in detention and instructions to witnesses
The Prosecution claims that, from April 12 to November 2, 2023, Hashim Thaçi tried to influence Prosecution witnesses in the trial for war crimes against him, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi and Jakup Krasniqi.
According to the indictment, Thaçi led or organized three separate groups, which included, respectively, Fadil Fazliu, Bashkim Smakaj and Isni Kilaj.
The Prosecution claims that, during detention visits, Thaçi disclosed the identities of some witnesses who were at the time confidential and gave visitors instructions to convey to the witnesses what they should say in court.
Thaçi faces 11 counts in the indictment, of which three are for attempting to obstruct officials in the performance of official duties, four for violating the confidentiality of proceedings and four for contempt of court.
One of the cases described in the indictment relates to the visit of Fadil Fazliu on 2 July 2023. According to the Prosecution, Thaçi gave Fazliu detailed instructions to pass on to the person identified in the indictment as witness 1.
According to the indictment, they agreed that Fazliu’s son, Fahri Fazliu, would contact the witness to arrange a meeting. The following day, on 3 July, Fahri Fazliu is said to have exchanged messages with the witness to organize a meeting among the three.
On 3 September 2023, Thaçi was visited by Hajredin Kuçi, who at the time was part of Kadri Veseli’s defense team.
According to the indictment, Thaçi gave Kuçi instructions to pass on to three witnesses, identified in the indictment as numbers 2, 5 and 6, on how they should testify. The Prosecution claims that Kuçi agreed with the instructions and made suggestions regarding what should be conveyed to witnesses 5 and 6.
Kuçi faces two counts of contempt of court. Smakaj, Kilaj and Fazliu each face one count of attempted obstruction of officials in the performance of official duties and one count of contempt of court.
On 9 September 2023, Thaçi was visited at the detention center in The Hague by former AKI director Bashkim Smakaj, Thaçi’s former advisers Blerim Shala and Artan Behrami, as well as other persons.
According to the indictment, Thaçi “repeatedly instructed one or more of the visitors to give witness 2 instructions on how to testify in the Thaçi and others case”.
When Smakaj and Behrami again visited Thaçi at the detention center on 7 October, he is suspected to have given further instructions on how witness 2 should testify.
On 30 October, during a search of Smakaj’s car, the Prosecution said it found a document with a version of events that, according to it, matched the instructions from both visits.
According to the Prosecution, Thaçi had printed the document on the detention center’s printer several hours before the 7 October visit.
One day before the visit by Smakaj and Behrami, on 6 October, Thaçi had been visited by Isni Kilaj and Vllaznim Kryeziu. According to the indictment, Thaçi gave them confidential information and asked them to pass on to protected witness 4 instructions on how he should testify.
During the search of Kilaj’s house on 2 November, the Prosecution said it found in the waste pages torn from the witness’s previous statements. According to it, they had been printed on the same printer as the document found in Smakaj’s car. The printing log, according to the Prosecution, showed that the part to which Thaçi is suspected to have referred during the meeting had been printed two days before the 6 October visit.
At Kilaj’s house, the Prosecution said it also found notes with witness codes and summaries of the testimony they were expected to give.
Nine recordings of conversations
At the start of the trial for obstruction of justice, on 27 February 2026, the Prosecution also presented other evidence, including recordings of conversations during visits to the detention center.
The Prosecution said that recordings of nine visits, made with judicial authorization, had been admitted as evidence. In its closing statement, the prosecutor spoke of about 28 hours of recordings.
At the opening session, several parts of the conversations were presented, including an excerpt from the July 2, 2023 meeting between Thaçi and Fadil Fazliu. In that excerpt, Thaçi is heard telling his interlocutor: “Say it briefly, ‘yes’, ‘no’, don’t philosophize.”
Prosecution claimed the conversation related to how Rrustem Mustafa, former KLA commander known as Commander Remi, should testify.
In another excerpt, from the October 6 meeting with Isni Kilaj and Vllaznim Kryeziu, the Prosecution said Thaçi referred to part of protected witness 4’s earlier statement, mentioning part 6, page 7 and line 9.
According to the Prosecution, Thaçi wanted the witness to change that part during the preparatory meeting with prosecutors, before testifying in court.
The prosecutor linked that excerpt to the page reconstructed from scraps of paper found in Kilaj’s waste. He said that on that page, the questions and answers beginning exactly at line 9 were circled by hand. They concerned Thaçi’s alleged involvement in the mistreatment of the witness.
What did the defense say about the charges?
Hashim Thaçi pleaded not guilty in writing on January 6, 2025. Thaçi pleaded not guilty again on April 24, after the indictment was amended to include incitement as an additional basis for criminal liability in three counts for attempted obstruction of official persons.
In the closing argument on September 10, 2026, Thaçi’s lawyer, Sophie Menegon, asked that he be found not guilty on all counts of the indictment. She challenged the reliability of the transcripts prepared by the Prosecution, saying that parts of the recordings were inaudible and that this cast doubt on the conclusions the Prosecution drew from the conversations.
“The SPO has never proved that the alleged members of the group intended to take joint action to obstruct the work of court officials,” she said.
Menegon argued that the request for a six-year prison sentence is “unreasonable” for words Thaçi is alleged to have said in the detention center.
She said that “nothing further happened” after Thaçi’s conversations with his co-defendants.
“Regardless of what may have been said or agreed, none of them had any impact at all on the witnesses or the SPO. There is no claim that any witness was interfered with, that any witness was intimidated, or that their testimony was changed,” Menegon had argued at the September 10 hearing.
According to the Prosecution, for the attempted charges, what mattered was whether the accused had taken steps to interfere with evidence, regardless of whether the efforts had succeeded./REL/
