
Democratic Party MP Jorida Tabaku, chair of the Committee on Human Rights and Public Information Media, used the committee meeting to raise the opposition’s concerns about the violence against protesters over the past 14 days.
Tabaku said she had requested that the Minister of Interior, Ervin Demo, and the General Director of the State Police, Skënder Hitaj, report to the committee to explain the cases of violence reported during the protests.
Tabaku’s positions were opposed by Socialist MP Ardit Bido, who described them as “theater”.
Responding to the request for a hearing with the Minister of Interior, Bido said Demo had been ready to report at the previous plenary session in Parliament, but his report had become impossible, according to the Socialist, due to the chaos created by opposition MPs.
Excerpt from the debate:
Tabaku: After 150 days of protests, two weeks ago, students began their own engagement. The students’ protest made all of us reflect, and I believed there would be reflection from the majority as well. A protest against what this parliament has produced, a policy without representation, which today, unfortunately, makes decisions by raising the card, without bringing any improvement to citizens’ lives.
A protest that began peacefully and then escalated, witnessing unprecedented violence on the streets of Tirana, the likes of which had not been seen since the fall of communism.
On behalf of the opposition, I have requested that Ervin Demo, Skënder Hitaj and the Commissioner for Protection from Discrimination report to this committee, because we have seen the violence on the streets of Tirana. I assure you, without any political connotation, that barbarity has been committed against young people. 1,000 young people have been detained, 250 of whom are minors.
I am in favor of the use of institutions, without question, but we must give some value to parliament. The Minister of Interior must definitely report. As a committee, we also need to discuss the situation with the media. 47 journalists have been threatened, intimidated and attacked; in 43 cases, this was done by the police.
All of this gets a response from the government: the new package on gatherings. In the morning it calls for dialogue, in the afternoon it beats people, and at night it says that anyone who gathers with three people will be fined, and anyone who goes to a protest will be fined. What are these communisms? Do you want to bring them back after 36 years?
Bido: With the full will of the Socialist Party parliamentary group, we want the Minister of Interior to report. The minister himself will report. What is happening is the theatrical play of the opposition, which, at the last session, had the minister’s report as its first item, and instead of holding him accountable for what you judge to be violations of human rights, you chose to commit other violations of parliamentary ethics, by assaulting fellow MPs, preventing parliamentary debate and institutional accountability, and by lowering the value of parliament and public and parliamentary life in the country.
Hence, this theatrical play must end. It must end now, when we are demanding the minister’s report, which was made impossible for him to deliver in the session by you, not by us. You displayed a physical strength that your colleagues do not have, but you show it in a theatrical performance. When I see the general secretary of your party looming in the session, what do you have him for?
Tabaku: Speak with respect, at least. Don’t say: “What do you have him for?”
Bido: What do you have, then? Why, do I have him? You have him.
Tabaku: What does it matter who has him? Speak with respect, because he is your fellow MP.
Bido: A fellow MP earns respect at the moment he behaves as befits parliament, not when he flexes muscles he does not have in order to devalue parliamentary and public life.
We have the opportunity to talk about essential issues, to talk about the social package that comes to us in a few days, to talk about pre-trial detention, not to talk only when it suits us, saying that pre-trial detention is unacceptable and that we are the black sheep of Europe when it comes to this issue.
A party that hides the violence we see, where masked protesters, who present themselves as students but are in fact Democratic Party militants, break into Democratic Party offices and take Molotov cocktails to throw at police and public property. You cannot preach morality at the moment you push and commit violence, not only in our public life but also in parliamentary life. If you cannot denounce and condemn violence, don’t put on theater.
